HomeStories briefbriefReader's CommentsFunding

What's new?

1971 talk on Meditation

Like a Foreign country

International Launch: FROM LION'S JAWS

On Shechen Kongtrül


Tribute to Ani Migme

Available for the first time: Audio Recordings of Trungpa Rinpoche's Vajrayogini Teachings

Conversation with Clarke Warren: Part Three

Glimpses of Mahamudra:
An Online Course taught by Judith L. Lief

84000 Posts New Translations in their Online Reading Room

Presentations of the Ngöndro for the Vidyadhara's Termas

In the Kitchen at BPB

Conversation with David Rome Part 3: In the years since ...

Ocean Open House on The Sanity We Are Born With, Tuesday Evening

Ocean Class: Cutting Through Spiritual Materialism start this Wednesday

Ocean: Registration open for autumn classes

Conversation with Clarke Warren: Part One

Ri-me Society Announcement:
Form from Space

Halifax Announcement:
Lee Weingrad Presentation Sept 9 & 10

Tribute to Olive Colón

Dennis Southward: Looking in the same direction

Chakrasamvara Empowerment in New York State this October

Khentrul Rinpoche on Jonang Kalachakra, Shambhala, and the Shentong Middle Way View

Summer Classes: Registration is now open

The Big Thud, a brief encounter from Karen Ritchie

A Conversation With David Rome


An interview with Jack Niland

Tribute to Acharya Allyn Lyon

Chogyam Trungpa in Mousehole

Tribute to Binny

Twenty-Nine years ago in the upper meadow ...

Nothing Else,
By Scott Wellenbach

CTR Retreat:
A Report from James Wilton

Translators Share Top Award

Orgyen Tobgyal Rinpoche on Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche

Oxford Refuge for Buddhist Monks

Tribute to Suzanne Duarte

Tribute to George Marshall

Jigme Phuntsok On Trungpa Rinpoche

Vajrayogini Abhisheka to be conferred

"No One Has Ever Been There"

The Escape's Place in History

A salute from Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche

Eleven years of poems and tributes including three poems from April 4, 2016

Trungpa Rinpoche on The Dawn of Enlightenment

An excerpt from an upcoming new book about Trungpa Rinpoche's escape from Tibet

Controversial New Mindfulness Study

An audio Valentine from Chögyam Trungpa

Shambhala Announces Larry Mermelstein's retirement as an acharya

Tribute to Maggie Russell

Shambhala Day Address from 1980

Ocean Update

Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche on the Passing of Chatral Rinpoche

Westchester Buddhist Center's Annual Meditation Retreat

Tribute to William Gilkerson

Boston Buddhadharma Invitation: Weekend Retreat, April 2016

Tribute to Andrew MacLean

Devotion: Lama Ugyen Shenpen's Home Video of the Lineage

It was the memory of his kindness, a brief encounter by James Edward Reid



Glimpses of Mahamudra, Practice Teachings of Chogyam Trungpa

Winter Meditation Retreat

Kindness in the Trenches

Announcing: Ocean's Autumn Classes

Community Talk from 1977

Tribute to Selda Chender

Stayed in Tibet

Halifax News: Robert Dvorkin Plays Benefit Concert

Boulder News: A public talk and seminar with Sam Bercholz

Honouring the
Vajra Regent

Two Opportunities for Intensive Meditation Retreat Practice

Tribute to Pamela Krasney

Tribute to David Harding

Climbing a Staircase, a Brief Encounter by William Hope

Lama Chime on Trungpa Rinpoche 50 Years On

Tribute to Jill Scott

Very sad news from Karma Senge Rinpoche

Derek Kolleeny Part 2: Westchester Buddhist Center

Joining Heart and Mind: An Evening with the Karmapa

First hand account from Nepal

Emptiness, Luminosity, and Compassion: The Path of Tantra Mahamudra, With Dorje Loppon, Lodro Dorje

Interview with Vana Jakic

Tribute to Gail Mueller

A book review by Alan Sloan

May Nepal Endure as Vajra Nature, by Clarke Warren

A conversation with Derek Kolleeny about Trungpa Rinpoche's Diplomatic Corps

Ocean Class for vajrayana students based on the Vidyadhara's 1976 EVAM seminar

An evening with the Karmapa at the New York Ethical Cultural Society: 14 April 2015

Please Give Me Space, by Joan Whitacre

A Stone for your Headstone, by Deanna Dana

Trungpa Rinpoche on "The Teacher"

Ongoing Tributes to Chogyam Trungpa

The Winter It Is Past, sung by Jane Condon

Chogyam the Translator

The Karmapa speaks on interdependence at Harvard Divinity School

Parinirvana Weekend at Dorje Denma Ling with Acharya Marty Janowitz

Tribute to Aba McHardy

Book Giveaway: Mindfulness in Action

Buddhadharma Without Credentials

Smile at Fear, An Introduction to Chogyam Trungpa's Teachings on Bravery

Tribute to
Tom Ryken

Walking the Bodhisattva talk, with Marty Janowitz

Milarepa Day Offering

newsBiographyBibliographyChronologyContact UsLinks

Interview with Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche

17 September 2003

Ari GoldField was the Tibetan/English interpretor for this audience

Khenpo Rinpoche
Halifax, September 2003
Photo by Andy Karr

For many years now, the Shambhala community has been involved in something like a love affair with Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche, the extraordinary Kagyu yogi/scholar who reminds us every time we see him - with his songs, his teachings, and by his delightful presence - that everything is dependently arisen mere appearance.

I had the good fortune to interview Rinpoche while he was teaching at the Shambhala Center in Halifax this September. I was one in a line-up of morning audiences. When my turn came, I was ushered into his room and found him sitting cross-legged in the middle of his bed, back straight, eyes wide, shockingly alert. I set my laptop on the floor and began to offer three half-prostrations. Rinpoche begins to talk (or sing) while I'm doing prostrations. -WF, November 2003

[Khenpo Tsultrim Gyamtso Rinpoche sang the following lines while I offered prostrations]


You should type things in this outer ground of all: the computer.
You should store things in your inner ground of all: your base consciousness.
You should know that all of the appearances of samsara and nirvana manifest from the ultimate ground of all: the true nature of mind.
Know that everything is dependently arisen mere appearance.

KTGR: (in English) What is your name?

WF: Walter Fordham.

KTGR: What is your practice?

WF: Vajrayogini.

KTGR: What is your question?

WF: Sir, I am gathering stories from people who knew Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche. I'm compiling these into an oral history of his life. My passion is to tell the life story of Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche as completely as possible. Since his death, you have been one of the main teachers who have carried on the work of teaching his students. Even though you perhaps only met him a few times during his life, I feel that you may know him in a unique way through his students. So that's why I'm here today. I would like to ask you to speak about Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche, about his life and his teachings.

KTGR: In the Sadhana of Mahamudra, in the verse that begins, "In the mandala of mahamudra / Shines moonlight, pure and all-pervading ...," Trungpa Rinpoche perfectly conveys his enlightened intention. This verse is incredibly profound.

I have taught a lot at what were once the Dharmadhatu centers and now they are Shambhala Centers. Whenever I go to these centers, my awareness feels very bright and clear. This demonstrates to me how excellent the connection is between Trungpa Rinpoche and his students, how much faith the students have in Trungpa Rinpoche, and how great Trungpa Rinpoche's compassion and blessing were for his students. When I go to these centers, vajra songs of realization naturally come to mind. To me, that is a manifestation of Trungpa Rinpoche's great blessing.

I think that this blessing comes mainly from how much faith the students of Trungpa Rinpoche have in him. Now the older students of Trungpa Rinpoche are helping guide the younger students on the same path that they followed and that is an excellent way of serving their lama and shows how wonderfully Trungpa Rinpoche trained them.

Trungpa Rinpoche laid out very clearly the stages of the path of study and practice for the Buddhist path and the Shambhala path and bringing the two together. He gave extraordinary teachings about the practices and the view at every level. The older students, his direct students, worked very hard to practice on that path and to translate all of the texts associated with the practices of that path. Now it is so easy for the new students because the older ones have blazed the trail. There are so many older students who can teach and help the new students along. I think the new students are so fortunate; this is my opinion. The new students are like people who drive on the highways in the West. The highway has been built and they don't have to have any doubt about which way to go, they just get on the highway and they go. They are incredibly fortunate to have this opportunity.

WF: Sir, did Trungpa Rinpoche also blaze a highway for the Tibetan teachers who came to the West after him? Is the work that he did beneficial to yourself and the many Tibetan teachers who are now teaching dharma in the West? Has he made your job easier?

Halifax, September 2003
Photo by Andy Karr
KTGR: [Laughs] Definitely! Because the one who mainly spread the vajrayana in the West was Trungpa Rinpoche. By doing so he made it very easy for future lamas to come here and teach. You are absolutely right.

WF: In what way did his work prepare the ground for yourself and other teachers?

KTGR: The main thing was to make these stages of practice. By doing that, he taught westerners the dharma and he made them worthy vessels to receive the dharma teachings as they proceed along these stages. That's the main thing. Isn't that good?

WF: Yes!

KTGR: And the students, the original students, also deserve credit because these students were the first to learn the forms and structure of the different practices, and to translate the texts.

Now the community of students is guided by the Sakyong Mipham Rinpoche who is the son of Trungpa Rinpoche's enlightened body, and the son of his enlightened mind. That is extraordinary and at the same time, it is part of a very sound tradition. If you look at the Sakya tradition and the Mindrölling tradition of the Nyingma, the one who carries the lineage of the father yogi is the son of both the father's enlightened body and enlightened mind. When a realized yogi like Trungpa Rinpoche conceives a child, there is no way an ordinary sentient being could take it, to be in the womb of the mother. So the only ones who could take that, the only ones who could do that are extraordinary beings themselves. That is what Sakyong Mipham Rinpoche is. He is extraordinary. He is not like an ordinary tulku, not like an ordinary emanation. He is more extraordinary than that because he is both the son of Trungpa Rinpoche's enlightened body and the son of his enlightened mind. So he is extraordinary.

You also have all the acharyas, Trungpa Rinpoche's senior students. They are helping to spread the teachings of Trungpa Rinpoche to so many different people. That is also extraordinary and it is not a static situation. The acharyas will grow old and they will be replaced by new teachers and the newer students will become older students and they'll help to guide more newer students. So, therefore it is a good tradition.

I have traveled all over the world teaching the dharma and this is my experience. Even in Australia and New Zealand there are Shambhala Centers where the older students are helping the younger students. The younger students are so fortunate because the older students have blazed a trail for them and they can practice on it just like somebody driving down the freeway. I think it's possible in the future that the Shambhala tradition will even spread back to Tibet and China.

Since the Shambhala tradition makes the dharma available to people who work, it makes it available to everyone in the modern world. In a communist country like China, the monastic tradition, where people give up work to practice, is only available to a very small number of people. The communists think that when there are too many nuns and monks who are not working, other people have to support them. They think that it is not beneficial; that it is harmful to the society. So they put limits on the number of monks and nuns. But the Shambhala tradition, on the other hand, encourages people to work and practice dharma together. That can only be of benefit to the country. When people practice according to the Shambhala path, their minds become gentle and good, their conduct becomes good and upstanding. How could that hurt the country?

For example, look how many people came into Shambhala Centers in the old days and even now as hippies. You took drugs, [KTGR laughs] didn't listen to your parents, didn't want to work, and acted irresponsibly. Now, as a result of practicing on the path, you have been transformed and have became good people who are responsible [KTGR laughing during the translation] and respectful towards your parents and others. Now your parents like the Buddhist tradition too and that is of benefit to everybody.

When people develop good minds and good conduct, that helps the country, helps the society, and makes everybody happy. When you can practice the dharma while working then lots of people can practice. Even if everybody on the planet wanted to practice the dharma, they could, as long as there is a way for them to practice while they work. The Shambhala path of Buddhism makes it so easy because all the stages have been laid out; it is available to everybody. That's how it is. That's good isn't it?

WF: That's wonderful! In telling the story of Trungpa Rinpoche's life, what would you say is the unique quality of Trungpa Rinpoche? The unique quality in Tibet before he came to the West?

KTGR: That's something you should ask the people in Surmang, because they know the story of Trungpa Rinpoche's life in Tibet. The western students know the story of what he did in America and Europe. The story of how he escaped from Tibet and the difficulties he encountered as a refugee, Trungpa Rinpoche himself has told in Born in Tibet.

Trungpa Rinpoche's famous because he gave the empowerments of the Rinchen Terdzö when he was only 13 years old. So he's renowned for having brought his prajna to perfection at a very young age. I am not sure, but I think he's probably the only one who did something like that at a young age. That's how it is.

Halifax, September 2003
Photo by Andy Karr

WF: I feel that we, his western students, can tell the outer story of his life. But I worry that we may have difficulty understanding the deeper meaning, the inner and secret stories of his life. Can you shed any light on the inner story and the secret story of Trungpa Rinpoche's life?

KTGR: The secret aspects of Trungpa Rinpoche's life story are revealed by Trungpa Rinpoche himself, at different times, to different people, in different ways. It's difficult to come up with one version of it. It's something that is revealed to people at large gradually over time.

WF: So we should wait?

KTGR: [Laughs] A little bit more time probably needs to pass.

KTGR: And then in terms of the story of his realization, then that is expressed for example in the Sadhana of Mahamudra where it says the yogi who is free from ordinary activity, and fearless, is happy, and free from hopes and fears about transversing the path and the bhumis ...

WF: Hey-ho!

KTGR: Right, so you know that. That's important. That's Trungpa Rinpoche's own experience of high level of realization—the level of realization of one who is free from ordinary activity, free from hope and fear, free from adopting and rejecting.

There are also all the things that Trungpa Rinpoche wrote and said publicly and privately; you have to examine all of that for yourselves. Some of his writings from Tibet, you have to understand, were written to be in harmony with the way Tibetans think. So you have to decide what to do with that. For example, in some lamas' songs of realization and in their writings, they criticize monks a lot. The monks that live in the monastery, they criticize them a lot, because they are looking after the monks all the time. So that's why they criticize them a lot.

WF: Rinpoche, when did you meet Trungpa Rinpoche?

KTGR: Once in Boulder and once at Shambhala Mountain Center. It was probably Boulder.

WF: And could you share your experience of meeting Trungpa Rinpoche?

KTGR: As Milarepa sings:

Halifax, September 2003
Photo by Andy Karr

E ma, the phenomena of the three realms of samsara
While not existing they appear.
How incredibly amazing.

My experience of meeting Trungpa Rinpoche was an experience of the wonder of appearance and emptiness—the wonder of having all thoughts be self-liberated. Since he himself is a yogi free of ordinary concepts, then my experience of meeting him was an experience like that. There wasn't a lot to talk about.

As Trungpa Rinpoche sings in the Sadhana of Mahamudra,[KTGR paraphrases:] Hey-ho the fearless yogi free from ordinary activity, free from adopting and rejecting, free from hopes and fears about the paths and bhumis.

That's what my experience of him was like. I didn't encounter that verse before I met Trungpa Rinpoche; I read it later. But when I did, I knew that this is what my experience of him was like. That's why I didn't need to talk to him a lot. Just to see him was enough. [KTGR laughs]

That's good, so now you should write this life story slowly, carefully.

The photographs on this page were taken by Andrew Karr on the morning of the interview.